Pat McAfee was revealed Friday night on WWE SmackDown as the person who had been talking with Randy Orton on the phone, and the reaction was mixed at best. By Saturday evening, the angle had become more than a surprise segment. It was being described as a source of frustration behind the scenes.
The timing is what made it land so hard. McAfee was inserted into the WWE Title program two weeks out from WrestleMania 42, and multiple reports said the move came from TKO Executive Chairman Ari Emanuel. Emanuel is said to think highly of McAfee, and Sean Ross Sapp of Fightful Select reported that the decision was made to drive interest in the show and create corporate synergy between WWE and.
That explanation did not settle matters internally. A separate report said Cody Rhodes and members of the WWE creative team took issue with TKO getting involved with storylines, and Rhodes was instructed to cut an unscheduled, shoot-style promo in response to McAfee's words earlier in the night. The online reaction, meanwhile, only deepened the debate over how the segment was put together and who was really steering it.
Read Also: Haley Z. Boston Reports Netflix Has Not Renewed Season 2 — Stranger Things
Sapp said there were a number of people who were not in favor of the direction of the “this place sucks” angle and believed those kinds of spots rarely work in pro wrestling. He also said the internal response was mixed, though the company was well aware of the reaction online. Some internally chalked the reaction up to heat, while others said it was not the kind of heat the company needed.
That distinction matters because the report put McAfee's return storyline above Triple H's head, which is why the online backlash quickly turned into a larger question about control of the show. The issue was not just whether the angle got attention. It was whether the attention helped or whether it exposed a split over how far TKO should reach into creative decisions this close to WrestleMania 42.
Read Also: Final 14 Jake Thistle American Idol Faces April 6 Top 12 Reveal
For now, the answer is plain enough. The McAfee angle did exactly what it was designed to do: it got people talking. What remains unresolved is whether the conversation around it helps the title program or underscores a creative power struggle that WWE would rather keep off camera.
